Deep Chlorophyll Maxima (DCMs) are ubiquitous in low-latitude oceans, and of recognized biogeochemical and ecological importance. DCMs have been observed in the Southern Ocean, initially from ships and recently from profiling robotic floats, but with less understanding of their onset, duration, underlying drivers, or whether they are associated with enhanced biomass features. We report the characteristics of a DCM and DBM (Deep Biomass Maximum) in the Inter-Polar-Frontal-Zone (IPFZ) south of Australia from CTD profiles, shipboard-incubated samples, a towbody, and a BGC-ARGO float. The DCM and DBM were ~20 m thick and co-located with the nutricline, in the vicinity of a subsurface ammonium maximum characteristic of the IPFZ, but ~100 m shallower than the ferricline. Towbody transects demonstrated that the co-located DCM/DBM was broadly present across the IPFZ. Large healthy diatoms, with low iron requirements, resided within the DCM/DBM, and fixed up to 20 mmol C m-2 d-1. The BGC-ARGO float revealed the DCM/DBM persisted for >3 months. We propose a dual environmental mechanism to drive DCM/DBM formation and persistence within the IPFZ: sustained supply of both recycled iron within the subsurface ammonium maxima and upward silicate transport from depth. DCM/DBM cell-specific growth rates were considerably slower than those in the overlying mixed layer, implying that phytoplankton losses are also reduced, possibly as a result of heavily silicified diatom frustules. The light-limited seasonal termination of the observed DCM/DBM did not result in a ‘diatom dump’, rather ongoing diatom downward export occurred throughout its multi-month persistence.

Abstract Ocean Iron Fertilization (OIF) aims to remove carbon dioxide (CO2) from the atmosphere by stimulating phytoplankton carbon-fixation and subsequent deep ocean carbon sequestration in iron-limited oceanic regions. Transdisciplinary assessments of OIF have revealed overwhelming challenges around the detection and verification of carbon sequestration and wide-ranging environmental side-effects, thereby dampening enthusiasm for OIF. Here, we utilize 5 requirements that strongly influence whether OIF can lead to atmospheric CO2 removal (CDR): The requirement (1) to use preformed nutrients from the lower overturning circulation cell; (2) for prevailing Fe-limitation; (3) for sufficient underwater light for photosynthesis; (4) for efficient carbon sequestration; (5) for sufficient air-sea CO2 transfer. We systematically evaluate these requirements using observational, experimental, and numerical data to generate circumpolar maps of OIF (cost-)efficiency south of 60°S. Results suggest that (cost-)efficient CDR is restricted to locations on the Antarctic Shelf. Here, CDR costs can be <100 US$/tonne CO2 while they are mainly >>1000 US$/tonne CO2 in offshore regions of the Southern Ocean, where mesoscale OIF experiments have previously been conducted. However, sensitivity analyses underscore that (cost-)efficiency is in all cases associated with large variability and are thus difficult to predict, which reflects our insufficient understanding of the relevant biogeochemical and physical processes. While OIF implementation on Antarctic shelves appears most (cost-)efficient, it raises legal questions because regions close to Antarctica fall under 3 overlapping layers of international law. Furthermore, the constraints set by efficiency and costs reduce the area suitable for OIF, thereby likely reducing its maximum CDR potential.

Manganese (Mn) is an essential element for photosynthetic life, yet concentrations in Southern Ocean open waters are very low, resulting from biological uptake along with limited external inputs. At southern latitudes, waters overlying the Antarctic shelf are expected to have much higher Mn concentrations due to their proximity to external sources such as sediment and sea ice. In this study, we investigated the potential export of Mn-rich Antarctic shelf waters toward depleted open Southern Ocean waters. Our results showed that while high Mn concentrations were observed over the shelf, strong biological uptake decreased dissolved Mn concentrations in surface waters north of the Southern Antarctic Circumpolar Current Front (< 0.1 nM), limiting export of shelf Mn to the open Southern Ocean. Conversely, in bottom waters, mixing between Mn-rich Antarctic Bottom Waters and Mn-depleted Low Circumpolar Deep Waters combined with scavenging processes led to a decrease in dissolved Mn concentrations with distance from the coast. Subsurface dissolved Mn maxima represented a potential reservoir for surface waters (0.3 – 0.6 nM). However, these high subsurface values decreased with distance from the coast, suggesting these features may result from external sources near the shelf in addition to particle remineralization. Overall, these results imply that the lower-than-expected lateral export of trace metal-enriched waters contributes to the extremely low (< 0.1 nM) and potentially co-limiting Mn concentrations previously reported further north in this Southern Ocean region.

Phytoplankton indirectly influence the climate, through their role in the ocean biological carbon pump. Hence factors limiting phytoplankton growth directly impact the strength of the biological carbon pump and consequently climate. In the Southern Ocean, the subantarctic zone represents an important carbon sink, yet variables limiting phytoplankton growth are not fully constrained. Co-limitation by iron (Fe) and manganese (Mn) has recently been observed in the coastal and offshore Southern Ocean, but very few studies have focused on the subantarctic zone. In addition, no study has investigated the seasonal variability of Mn (co-)limitation of phytoplankton growth in the Southern Ocean. Using three shipboard bioassay experiments, we evaluated the seasonality of Fe and Mn co-limitation of subantarctic phytoplankton growth, south of Tasmania. We observed a strong seasonal variation in phytoplankton Fe limitation, and that the response of phytoplankton to Mn was subtle and thus readily masked by the responses to Fe. Combined addition of Fe and Mn enhanced carbon uptake of nanoeukaryotes in spring and microeukaryotes in summer while the addition of Mn alone stimulated the growth of picocyanobacteria in autumn. These results suggest the importance of Mn may vary seasonally and its control on phytoplankton growth may be associated with specific taxa.

In the Subantarctic sector of the Southern Ocean, vertical entrainment of dissolved iron (DFe) triggers the seasonal productivity cycle. However, diminishing physical supply of new Fe during the spring to summer transition rapidly drives epipelagic microbial communities to rely upon recycled DFe for growth. Hence, subpolar waters evolve seasonally from a high fe ratio system (i.e., [uptake of new Fe]/[uptake of new+recycled Fe]) to a low fe ratio system. Here, we tested how resident microbes within a cyclonic eddy respond to different Fe/ligand inputs which mimic entrained new DFe (Fe-NEW), diffusively-supplied regenerated DFe (Fe-REG), and a control with no addition of DFe (Fe-NO). After 6 days, 3.5 (Fe-NO, Fe-NEW) to 5-fold (Fe-REG) increases in Chl a were observed despite ~2.5-fold range between treatments of initial DFe. Marked differences were also evident in the proportion of in vitro DFe derived from recycling to sustain phytoplankton growth (Fe-REG, 30% recycled c.f. 70% Fe-NEW, 50% Fe-NO). This trend supports the concept that DFe/ligands released from subsurface particles are more bioavailable than new DFe collected at the same depth. This additional recycling may be mediated by bacteria. Indeed, by day 6 bacterial production (BP) was comparable between Fe-NO and Fe-NEW but~2 fold higher in Fe-REG. Interestingly, a preferential response of phytoplankton (haptophyte-dominated) relative to bacteria was also found in Fe-REG. In contrast, in Fe-NEW and Fe-NO the proportion of diatoms increased. Hence, different modes of Fe/ligand supply modify BP and Fe bioavailability to phytoplankton that may drive distinctive floristic shifts and biogeochemical signatures.

The necessity to understand the influence of global ocean change on biota has exposed wide-ranging gaps in our knowledge of the fundamental principles that underpin marine life. Concurrently, physiological research has stagnated, in part driven by the advent and rapid evolution of molecular biological techniques, such that they now influence all lines of enquiry in biological and microbial oceanography. This dominance has led to an implicit assumption that physiology is outmoded, and advocacy that ecological and biogeochemical models can be directly informed by omics. However, the main modelling currencies continue to be biological rates and biogeochemical fluxes. Here we ask: how do we translate the wealth of information on physiological potential from omics-based studies to quantifiable physiological rates and, ultimately, to biogeochemical fluxes? Based on the trajectory of the state-of-the-art in biomedical sciences, along with case-studies from ocean sciences, we conclude that it is unlikely that omics can provide such rates in the coming decade. Thus, while physiological rates will continue to be central to providing projections of global change biology, we must revisit the metrics we rely upon. We advocate for the co-design of a new generation of rate measurements that better link the benefits of omics and physiology.