loading page

Reconciling Surface Deflections From Simulations of Global Mantle Convection
  • +4
  • Conor Patrick O'Malley,
  • Gareth G Roberts,
  • James Panton,
  • Fred D Richards,
  • J. Huw Davies,
  • Victoria M Fernandes,
  • Sia Ghelichkhan
Conor Patrick O'Malley
Imperial College London
Author Profile
Gareth G Roberts
Imperial College London

Corresponding Author:[email protected]

Author Profile
James Panton
Cardiff University
Author Profile
Fred D Richards
Imperial College London
Author Profile
J. Huw Davies
School of Earth and Ocean Sciences, Cardiff University
Author Profile
Victoria M Fernandes
GFZ Potsdam
Author Profile
Sia Ghelichkhan
Australian National University
Author Profile

Abstract

The modern state of the mantle and its evolution on geological timescales is of widespread importance for the Earth sciences. For instance, it is generally agreed that mantle flow is manifest in topographic and drainage network evolution, glacio-eustasy and in the distribution of sediments. There now exists a variety of theoretical approaches to predict histories of mantle convection and its impact on surface deflections. A general goal is to make use of observed deflections to identify Earth-like simulations and constrain the history of mantle convection. Several important insights into roles of radial and non-radial viscosity variations, gravitation, and the importance of shallow structure already exist. Here we seek to bring those insights into a single framework to elucidate the relative importance of popular modelling choices on predicted instantaneous vertical surface deflections. We start by comparing results from numeric and analytic approaches to solving the equations of motion that are ostensibly parameterised to be as-similar-as-possible. Resultant deflections can vary by $\sim$10\%, increasing to $\sim25$\% when viscosity is temperature-dependent. Including self-gravitation and gravitational potential of the deflected surface are relatively small sources of discrepancy. However, spherical harmonic correlations between model predictions decrease dramatically with the excision of shallow structure to increasing depths, and when radial viscosity structure is modified. The results emphasise sensitivity of instantaneous surface deflections to density and viscosity anomalies in the upper mantle. They reinforce the view that a detailed understanding of lithospheric structure is crucial for relating mantle convective history to observations of vertical motions at Earth’s surface.
26 Mar 2024Submitted to ESS Open Archive
12 Apr 2024Published in ESS Open Archive