As sea ice decreases, navigation in the Arctic is becoming more feasible, and new routes are likely to emerge. However, the impact of these potential routes on sea ice remains uncertain. In this study, we compare the regional impacts of two major Arctic routes: the Northern Sea Route (NSR) and the Transpolar Sea Route (TSR). Using the Community Earth System Model (CESM2), we simulate black carbon (BC) emissions until 2050 along these routes and assess their effects on Arctic sea ice (ASI). We focus on regional changes in net shortwave (SW) radiation, sea ice extent, and surface temperature. While our study does not account for other pollutants that could counteract BC effects, our results reveal significant differences in ASI's response between routes. The TSR, in particular, exerts a stronger and more widespread influence on ASI than the NSR across all seasons, especially in increasing net SW radiation over the ice.