Monod parameterization and competition at low iron among freshwater
cyanobacteria and chlorophytes
Abstract
1. This study combines two approaches to explore the utility of Monod
growth kinetics to predict competition outcomes between freshwater
cyanobacteria and chlorophytes at low iron Fe. Fe threshold
concentrations (FeT) below which growth ceases, and growth affinities
(slope of Fe concentration vs growth rate near FeT) were estimated for
three large-bodied cyanobacteria (two N-fixers and Microcystis) and two
chlorophytes in batch cultures. 2. Mean FeT for N-replete cyanobacteria,
N-deplete (when N-fixing) cyanobacteria and chlorophytes were 0.076,
0.736 and 0.245 nmol L-1 , respectively. Mean affinities were 0.937,
0.597 and 0.412 L nmol-1 d-1 , respectively. Assuming that the mean
affinities are representative of their groups, affinities predict that
N-replete cyanobacteria are more efficient at acquiring Fe than
chlorophytes and should dominate when Fe is low but greater than their
FeT. 3. A second study evaluated the competitive abilities of a
pico-cyanobacterium and a third chlorophyte in dual species, serial
dilution culture. The pico-cyanobacterium was dominant at 50 nmol L-1
total Fe (which limited both taxa) and 500 nmol L-1 total Fe. At 0.5
nmol L-1 total Fe, a stressful concentration below FeT during most of
the incubation, growth rates and cell densities were extremely low but
neither had washed out after several months. 4. These results show that
Monod kinetics can successfully predict competition outcomes in
laboratory settings at low Fe. While important, Monod kinetics are only
one mechanism governing competition between cyanobacteria and eukaryotes
in natural systems. Observed deviations from Monod predictions can be
partially explained with known mechanisms.