Adam Matthew Forte

and 3 more

The Greater Caucasus (GC) Mountains within the central Arabia-Eurasia collision zone, are an archetypal example of a young collisional orogen. However, the mechanisms driving rock uplift and forming the topography of the range are controversial, with recent provocative suggestions that uplift of the western GC is strongly influenced by an isostatic response to slab detachment, whereas the eastern half has grown through shortening and crustal thickening. Testing this hypothesis is challenging because records of exhumation rates mostly come from the western GC, where slab detachment may have occurred. To address this data gap, we report 623 new, paired zircon U-Pb and (U-Th)/He ages from 7 different modern river sediments, spanning a ~400 km long gap in bedrock thermochronometer data. We synthesize these with prior bedrock thermochronometer data, recent catchment averaged 10Be cosmogenic exhumation rates, topographic analyses, structural observations, and plate reconstructions to evaluate the mechanisms growing the GC topography. We find no evidence of major differences in rates, timing of onset of cooling, or total amounts of exhumation across the possible slab edge, inconsistent with previous suggestions of heterogeneous drivers for exhumation along-strike. Comparison of exhumation across timescales highlight a potential acceleration, but one that appears to suggest a consistent northward shift of the locus of more rapid exhumation. Integration of these new datasets with simple models of orogenic growth suggest that the gross topography of the GC is explainable with traditional models of accretion, thickening, and uplift and does not require any additional slab-related mechanisms.

Jacqueline Giblin

and 3 more

Most thermochronological studies aimed at constraining exhumation rates rely on bedrock datasets. Often, they involve the analysis of samples collected along an elevation profile in terrains with high relief. However, there are several limitations to this approach, most importantly access to an appropriately steep traverse and sufficient relief to overcome uncertainties, and to have a broad enough range in closure ages as a function of elevation. Detrital thermochronology offers an alternative approach which can mitigate these challenges through coordinated dating of modern river sediments using multiple thermochronologic methods. Modern detrital sediments from active catchments provide an excellent source of material, typically rich in rock-forming and accessory minerals. Detrital thermochronologic data for material in sedimentary basins has been used widely to infer exhumation histories of sedimentary source terrains, reconstruct paleorelief, and evaluate spatial and temporal variations in erosion rates; however, there have been comparably fewer studies that apply this technique to evaluate regional exhumation patterns using detrital samples from active catchments. Based on the approach presented in Gallagher and Parra, (2020), we are exploring the capability of detrital thermochronologic data to infer regional exhumation patterns in the southeastern Sierra Nevada, CA. Here the uplift history remains debated and the potential mechanism of uplift has yet to be thoroughly constrained. Many catchments along the eastern side of the Sierra Nevada exhibit advantageous characteristics for detrital thermochronologic studies, including steep topography and high relief (that make it more difficult to sample bedrock), limited lithologic variability (which minimizes point-source biasing), relatively simple geologic structure, and relatively easy access to detrital sampling localities. Additionally, the dominant source of the southeastern Sierra Nevada catchments, the igneous units of the Sierra Nevada batholith, include abundant rock-forming minerals for 40Ar/39Ar thermochronology (hornblende, biotite, and sometimes muscovite) as well as abundant accessory minerals for (U-Th)/Pb geochronology(zircon), (U-Th)/Pb thermochronology (apatite), and (U-Th)/He thermochronology (zircon and apatite). Collectively, detrital thermochronological data from these minerals can elucidate much of the post-crystallization thermal history of the eastern flank of the Sierra Nevada. Preliminary results of this technique demonstrate the potential of this cost- and labor-efficient approach for exhumation history studies.