The role of mutualism in marine benthic communities: Key species are
affected by predicted warming but show resistance to ocean acidification
Abstract
The effects of climate change on coastal biodiversity are a major
concern because altered community compositions may change associated
rates of ecosystem functioning and services. While responses of single
species or taxa have been studied extensively, it remains challenging to
estimate responses to climate change across different levels of
biological organisation. Studies that consider the effects of moderate
realistic near-future levels of ocean warming and acidification are
needed to identify scope for adaptation and evolution. Also, studies
including different levels of biological complexity may reveal
opportunities for amelioration or facilitation under changing
environmental conditions. To test experimentally for independent and
combined effects of predicted near-future warming and acidification on
key benthic species, we manipulated three levels of temperature
(ambient, +0.8 °C, +2 °C) and two levels of pCO2 (ambient at 450 ppm,
elevated at 645 ppm) and quantified their effects on mussels and algae
growing separately or together (to also test for inter-specific
interactions). Warming increased mussel clearance and mortality rates
simultaneously, which meant that total biomass peaked at + 0.8 °C.
Surprisingly, however, no effects of elevated pCO2 were identified on
mussels or algae. Moreover, when kept together, mussels and algae had
mutually positive effects on each other’s performance (i.e. mussel
survival and condition index, mussel and algal biomass, and proxies for
algal productivity including relative maximum electron transport rate
[rETRmax], saturating light intensity [Ik], and maximum quantum
yield [Fv/Fm]), independent of warming and acidification. Our
results show that even moderate warming affected the functioning of key
benthic species, and we identified a level of resistance to predicted
ocean acidification. Importantly, we show that the presence of a second
functional group enhanced the functioning of both groups (mussels and
algae), independent of changing environmental conditions, which
highlights the ecological and potential economic benefits of conserving
biodiversity in marine ecosystems.