Phytoplankton communities in the open ocean are high-dimensional, sparse, and spatiotemporally heterogeneous. The advent of automated imaging systems has enabled high-resolution observation of these communities, but the amounts of data and their statistical properties make analysis with traditional approaches challenging. Spatiotemporal topic models offer an unsupervised and interpretable approach to dimensionality reduction of sparse, high-dimensional categorical data. Here we use topic modeling to analyze neural-network-classified phytoplankton imagery taken in and around a retentive eddy during the 2021 North Atlantic EXport Processes in the Ocean from Remote Sensing (EXPORTS) field campaign. We investigate the role physical-biological interactions play in altering plankton community composition within the eddy. Analysis of a water mass mixing framework suggests that storm-driven surface advection and stirring were major drivers of the progression of the eddy plankton community away from a diatom bloom over the course of the cruise.