Constraints on Southern Ocean Shortwave Cloud Feedback from the
Hydrological Cycle
Abstract
Shifts in Southern Ocean (SO, 40-85S) shortwave (SW) cloud feedback
(SWFB) towards more positive values are the dominant contributor to
higher effective climate sensitivity (ECS) in Coupled Model
Intercomparison Project phase 6 (CMIP6) models. The positive shift in
SWFB in CMIP6 global climate model (GCMs) can be traced back to the
greater reduction in low cloud cover and the weaker cloud liquid water
response to warming in the SO. To evaluate how realistic the CMIP6 cloud
response is, we connect the SO SWFB to changes in column-integrated
liquid water mass (LWP) and the susceptibility of albedo to LWP in 50
CMIP5 and CMIP6 GCMs. In turn, we predict the responses of SO LWP to
warming using a cloud-controlling factor (CCF) model. The combination of
the CCF model and radiative susceptibility explains about 50% of the
variance in the GCM-simulated SWFB in the SO. Observations of SW
radiation fluxes, LWP, and reanalysis of CCFs are used to constrain the
SO SWFB. This yields a constrained response of SO LWP to warming of
2.89-4.41 gm-2K-1, relative to the total GCM range of -0.48-9.33
gm-2K-1. The susceptibility of albedo to LWP is constrained to be
0.41-0.86 (kgm-2)-1, relative to the GCM range of 0.23-3.62 (kgm-2)-1,
where albedo is unitless. The overall constraint on the contribution of
SO SWFB to global cloud feedback is -0.19-0.05 Wm-2K-1, relative to GCM
range of -0.28-0.27 Wm-2K-1. In summary, observations suggest a moderate
negative to weak positive SO SWFB.