Low energy expenditure at the edge of a seabird's winter range suggests
energy underpins the Abundant Centre Hypothesis
Abstract
Understanding how geographic range limits are shaped is a central and
challenging question in ecology that has become particularly critical in
the context of global environmental changes. While such limits are often
studied for resident or breeding species, range limits are equally
important for migratory species in winter when population regulation may
occur due to limited resources in the non-breeding season. A central
hypothesis in several theories for range limitations is that the
density, fitness and performance of individuals decrease towards the
edge of the range as organisms become maladapted when approaching the
limit of their environmental tolerance (‘Abundant-centre Hypothesis’).
Energy is a critical resource, especially in winter when environmental
conditions deteriorate, and this hypothesis predicts that high energy
expenditure (low performance) at the range limit would lead to rapidly
dwindling body mass and reduced fitness. We investigated this hypothesis
in an Arctic-breeding seabird wintering in the North-Atlantic, the
black-legged kittiwake (Rissa tridactyla). From 2008 to 2019, we tracked
117 adult kittiwakes (n=176 tracks) with geolocation devices and
saltwater immersion sensors to estimate the migratory strategies,
time-activity budget and energy expenditure of individuals during
winter, and estimated their reproductive success after their return to
the colony during summer. Population density was indeed higher towards
the center of the range. However, contrary to the predictions, the
energy expenditure of individuals was higher at the centre of the range
and decreased towards the edge. In contrast, there were no spatial
differences in the reproductive success of individuals wintering at the
centre versus at the edge of their range. We conclude that performance
and fitness did not increase towards the centre of the wintering range,
implying that although resource acquisition was likely higher at the
abundant centre, energy expenditure was also higher, so that individual
fitness was constant across the winter range.