We investigate a fifteen-day period in October 2011. Auroral observations by the SSUSI instrument onboard the DMSP F16, F17, and F18 spacecraft indicate that the polar regions were covered by weak cusp-aligned arc emissions whenever the IMF clock angle was small, |θ|<45°, which amounted to 30% of the time. Simultaneous observations of ions and electrons in the tail by the Cluster C4 and Geotail spacecraft showed that during these intervals dense (1 cm-3) plasma was observed, even as far from the equatorial plane of the tail as |ZGSE| = 13 RE. The ions had a pitch angle distribution peaking parallel and antiparallel to the magnetic field and the electrons had pitch angles that peaked perpendicular to the field. We interpret the counter-streaming ions and double loss-cone electrons as evidence that the plasma was trapped on closed field lines, and acted as a source for the cusp-aligned arc emission across the polar regions. This suggests that the magnetosphere was almost entirely closed during these periods. We further argue that the closure occured as a consequence of dual-lobe reconnection at the dayside magnetopause. Our finding forces a significant re-evaluation of the magnetic topology of the magnetosphere during periods of northwards IMF.