1. Introduction
Premixed
gas burners used in boilers, heat pumps, hot water heaters and other
applications provide a high heat release in a small area while providing
low pollutant gas combustion product emissions. Burners which are used
in chemical and manufacturing processes often suffer from the problem of
matching the heat flux produced by the burner and placed into the space
to be heated in the furnace or heat exchanger to the actual load
required in order to maximize the amount of heat flux which is being
efficiently used, to further maximize the actual rate of production or
rate of the process and to reduce problems such as coking, in process
heaters for refineries, for example [1, 2]. Such burners, may also
occasionally suffer from operational drawbacks, such as instability of
the flame relative to the flame holder, which may be evidenced in terms
of lift off of the flame from the burner tile, or flame noise and
pulsation [3, 4]. In addition, such burners may often produce
undesirable levels of emissions, particularly oxides of nitrogen [5,
6]. Many conventional gas-fired burners use a diffusion flame
combustion process in which combustion occurs over a range of
equivalence ratios, including high temperature, lean regions where
thermal nitrogen oxides form [7, 8]. The term ”nitrogen oxides” is
intended to refer to any molecular species consisting of nitrogen and
oxygen [9, 10], for example, nitric oxide, nitrogen dioxide, nitrous
oxide, dinitrogen tetroxide, or combinations thereof. Nitrogen oxides
surface as pollutants in a wide variety of contexts. Primarily, nitrogen
oxides appear as pollutants in combustion processes. Many approaches
have been taken to affect the removal and decomposition of nitrogen
oxides from gaseous mixtures containing them [11, 12]. One known
method for reducing peak flame temperatures is to use a combustion
process which creates a fuel-rich primary combustion region and
subsequent air staging with corresponding heat loss, resulting in
lowering the overall combustion equivalence ratio to achieve complete
combustion [13, 14]. Another known method for reducing peak flame
temperatures relates to a combustion process that operates with a
fuel-lean primary combustion region and fuel staging in order to raise
the equivalence ratio [15, 16]. However, such known methods of
staged fuel combustion rely upon a diffusion flame to produce the lean
primary stage. External flue gas recirculation can be added to such
known methods for further reducing nitrogen oxides.
In the combustion of gaseous fuels, nitrogen oxides are formed primarily
through fixation of molecular nitrogen and oxygen in the combustion air
[17, 18]. It is known that thermal nitrogen oxides formation depends
on the existence of flame regions with relatively high temperatures and
excess oxygen [19, 20]. Many conventional combustion methods for
reducing nitrogen oxides are based upon avoiding such conditions [21,
22]. It is necessary to consider the prompt nitrogen oxides formation
process in order to reach very low nitrogen oxides levels. Reactions
between hydrocarbon fragments and molecular nitrogen can lead to the
formation of bound nitrogen species, such as hydrogen cyanide, which can
subsequently be oxidized to nitrogen monoxide. Such processes become
significant relative to the thermal mechanism under moderately fuel-rich
conditions at relatively low temperatures [23, 24]. Avoiding such
conditions can reduce prompt nitrogen oxides contributions.
Additionally, these burners often employ pilot flames for establishing
the primary flame region over the burner in a furnace [25, 26]. The
pilot, even though small in heat release may contribute to overall
burner emissions, particularly of oxides of nitrogen, under ultra-low
nitrogen oxides operation. It is of great importance to provide a burner
which has greatly reduced emissions, particularly of oxides of nitrogen
[27, 28]. It is also of great importance to provide a burner system
which is capable of enabling active management and variation of the heat
flux in order to allow for the optimization of the heating process and
modify the heat flux of the burner to avoid process shutdowns, while
maximizing furnace availability [29, 30]. It is very necessary to
provide a pilot for a burner, such as may be used in chemical plant
process heaters and the like, which provides the establishment of the
primary flame region while contributing less to the heat released by the
burner and contributing less to the emissions produced by the burner,
particularly oxides of nitrogen. It is also very necessary to provide a
gaseous fuel burner system which provides a well-organized flame with no
significant regions of lean high temperature conditions, which are known
to contribute to increased nitrogen oxides emissions.
Combustion processes which burn fossil fuels introduce emissions into
the atmosphere which have been linked with harmful effects.
Environmental regulations have been enacted to limit the concentrations
of these emissions in the exhaust gases from combustion processes [31,
32]. Nitrogen oxides emissions arise from nitrogen present in the
combustion air and from fuel-bound nitrogen in hydrocarbons if such
fuels are burned [33, 34]. Conversion of fuel-bound nitrogen to
nitrogen oxides depends on the amount and reactivity of the nitrogen
compounds in the fuel and the amount of oxygen in the combustion zone
[35, 36]. Conversion of fuel-bound nitrogen is not present in
processes using fuels, for example, natural gas, which contain no fixed
nitrogen compounds [37, 38]. Conversion of atmospheric nitrogen
present in the combustion air to nitrogen oxides is temperature
dependent. In general, the greater the flame temperature in the
combustion zone, the greater the resultant nitrogen oxides content in
the emissions. nitrogen oxides conversion increases drastically at
temperatures greater than 1800 K if oxygen is present.
Many industrial processes, such as forging, reheating, and melting of
glass or aluminum, are carried out in high temperature, gas-fired
furnaces [39, 40]. In such high temperature processes, air used in
the combustion process is frequently preheated. Preheating the air
reduces the amount of fuel needed, increasing thermal efficiency, but
increases the temperature of the flame, which increases nitrogen oxides
content [41, 42]. Thus, a higher temperature burner which is capable
of reducing nitrogen oxides emissions without sacrificing thermal
efficiency is needed [43, 44]. One way of reducing nitrogen oxides
content which has been effective in processes using nitrogen bearing
fuels is to create a fuel-rich combustion zone followed by a fuel-lean
combustion zone [45, 46]. This can be achieved by staging the
introduction of air into the combustion chamber. The fuel-rich zone
contains less than the theoretical or stoichiometric amount of oxygen.
Thus, less oxygen is available to convert the nitrogen-to-nitrogen
oxides. Recirculating flue gas into the flame is another technique to
limit nitrogen oxides emissions [47, 48]. The recirculated flue gas
reduces the oxygen concentration in the reactants and reduces the flame
temperature by cooling the combustion products, thereby lowering
nitrogen oxides content. Additionally, nitrogen oxides present in the
recirculated flue gas can be further destroyed by reburning. The flue
gases can also be used for other purposes, such as preheating the
combustion air or vaporizing liquid fuels.
Despite previous work, there are a number of answered questions
regarding flame stability at the microscale. Examples include the role
of wall material thermal conductivity in flame stability. The present
study is focused primarily upon the effect of wall material thermal
conductivity on the butane flame stability of microscale gas fired
burners. The two primary mechanisms for quenching in these burners are
thermal and radical quenching. Increased heat-transfer coefficients are
inherent to microscales, because for a fixed Nusselt number, the
heat-transfer coefficient scales with the inverse of the length scale.
The high heat-transfer rates increase the heat lost from the reaction,
reducing the operating temperatures and causing the combustion to
extinguish. At the same time, the increased mass transfer within the
system, coupled with the high surface-area-to-volume ratio, causes
radical adsorption onto the walls, followed by radical recombination.
This dearth of radicals quenches the homogeneous chemistry. Another
mechanism for loss of stability is blowout, which occurs when the burner
exit velocity exceeds the flame burning velocity. The present study aims
to provide a fundamental understanding of the butane flame stability of
microscale gas fired burners at different wall material thermal
conductivities. Particular emphasis is placed upon the stability limits
over a range of equivalence ratios and the effect of wall material
thermal conductivity on the butane flame stability.