Abstract
At least 37 studies demonstrate some degree of short-term influence of
CO2 on human cognition, broadly considered, at CO2 concentrations
frequently observed in buildings (>1000ppm). Ambient
concentrations of CO2 in some cities can exceed global average values by
several hundred ppm due to multiple large sources and idiosyncrasies of
atmospheric transport, diffusion, and dispersion. In those few cities
with extensive CO2 monitoring systems, local variations exceed 50ppm
along transport corridors or close to point sources such as power
plants. Scenarios of future CO2 concentrations project global average
values up to 950ppm by 2100. Combining these various influences suggests
that some locations in cities may regularly experience CO2
concentrations of 1300ppm by 2100. In occupied enclosed spaces such as
schoolrooms, CO2 concentrations can rise several thousand ppm above
ambient values. ASHRAE sets indoor air standards relative to ambient
levels, not as absolute levels. Highly energy efficient buildings reduce
air leakage and may have lower ventilation air exchange rates to reduce
energy loss. LEED standards do not address effects of certification
standards on CO2 concentrations. Cabs of vehicles and other enclosed
spaces in the transport sector also can be several thousand ppm above
ambient levels. Long-term exposure to elevated CO2 at these levels has
not been studied in humans but limited studies of mouse models
demonstrate respiratory impairments after three-month exposure to 890ppm
CO2 for newborn mice. We are unaware of any studies of health impacts of
CO2 on mice or humans that use pre-industrial concentrations of CO2 as
baseline values. Thus, experimental methodologies must be reformed and
standardized before we can fully appreciate how living in an elevated
CO2 world is already affecting human health. Connecting the dots between
these various influences suggests that exposure (particularly long-term
exposure) to CO2 concentrations that affect cognition may vary
significantly depending upon distance from active sources (power plants,
roadways) and occupation (e.g. truck driver), such effects will grow to
serious levels, may already exert a toll on human cognitive outcomes,
and could implicate environmental justice concerns.