loading page

TGE electron energy spectra: Comment on “Radar Diagnosis of the Thundercloud Electron Accelerator” by E. Williams et al. (2022)
  • +3
  • Ashot A. Chilingarian,
  • Gagik Hovsepyan,
  • Mary Zazyan,
  • Balabek Sargsyan,
  • Tigran KArapetyan,
  • Levon Vanyan
Ashot A. Chilingarian
Yerevan Physics Institute

Corresponding Author:[email protected]

Author Profile
Gagik Hovsepyan
Yerevan Physics Institute
Author Profile
Mary Zazyan
Yerevan Physics Institute
Author Profile
Balabek Sargsyan
Yerevan physics Institute
Author Profile
Tigran KArapetyan
yerevan physics institute
Author Profile
Levon Vanyan
yerevan physics institute
Author Profile

Abstract

Williams et al. (2022) questioned TGE electron energy spectra measured on Aragats; they conclude that “A more likely origin for any detected electrons at 3.2 km MSL is Compton scattering and pair production activated by longer-range bremsstrahlung gamma rays, themselves produced by runaway electron encounters with nuclei in breakeven field at higher altitude “.
In this comment, we show that the selection criteria of “electron” TGEs unambiguously reject the assumption on the origination of TGE electrons from the Compton process of the TGE gamma rays. Additionally, comparison of recovered gamma ray and electron energy spectra allows to estimate the height of the strong accelerating electric field above particle spectrometers and establish 24/7 monitoring of the horizontal profile of the atmospheric electric field during thunderstorms.