Lakes are often defined by seasonal cycles. The seasonal timing, or phenology, of many lake processes, such as primary productivity, are changing in response to human activities. However, long-term records exist for few lakes, and extrapolating patterns observed in these lakes to entire landscapes is exceedingly difficult using the limited number of in situ observations that are available. Limited landscape level observations means we do not know how common shifts in lake phenology are at macroscales. Here, we use a new remote sensing dataset, LimnoSat-US, to analyze U.S. summer lake color phenology between 1984 and 2020 across more than 26,000 lakes. Our results show that summer lake color seasonality can be generalized into five distinct phenology groups that follow well-known patterns of phytoplankton succession. The frequency with which lakes transition from one phenology group to another is tied to lake and landscape level characteristics. Lakes with high discharge and low variation in their seasonal extent are generally more stable while lakes in areas with high interannual variations in climate and catchment population density show less stability. Our research reveals previously unexamined spatiotemporal patterns in lake seasonality and demonstrates the utility of LimnoSat-US, which, with over 22 million remote sensing observations of lakes, creates novel opportunities to systematically examine changing lotic ecosystems at a national scale.