P. Stauning: Comment on “Troshichev et al. 2020: The PC index
variations during 23/24 solar cycles: relation to solar wind parameters
and magnetic disturbances.”: Invalid data base. Manuscript:
2021JA029151 Initial submission 4 February 2021. Submission of revised
version 16 April 2021
Abstract
P. Stauning: Comment on “Troshichev et al. 2020: The PC index
variations during 23/24 solar cycles: relation to solar wind parameters
and magnetic disturbances.”: Invalid data base. Abstract. The
contribution from O.A. Troshichev, S. Dolgacheva, N.A. Stepanov, and
D.A. Sormakov: “The PC index variations during 23/24 solar cycles:
relation to solar wind parameters and magnetic disturbances”,
https://doi.org/10.1029/2020JA028491 , is to a large extent based on
data made available at the web portal
http://geophys.aari.ru/PCspaceweather. However, an examination of the
data presented there has disclosed what appears to be serious errors in
the calculated values of polar cap (PC) index values, amplitude span of
the quiet day curves (QDC) used for the reference levels, and values of
the solar wind merging (or geoeffective) electric field (E KL) used for
calibration of polar magnetic data to form PC indices. Parts of the
essential data files are reproduced in the Appendix here. Some of the
discrepancies reported in the present commentary affect directly the
illustrations presented in their contribution while other possible
errors may not be apparent since the use of relative values in their
presentation makes assessments difficult.