The effect of optical dilatation before retrograde intrarenal surgery on
success and complications: results of the RIRSearch group study.
Abstract
Aims: The guidelines propose optical dilatation before retrograde
intrarenal surgery (RIRS), but there are no evidence-based studies
concerning the impact of optical dilatation with semirigid ureteroscopy
(sURS) in the literature. The aim of this study was to evaluate the
effect of optical dilatation through sURS prior to the procedure on the
success and complications of RIRS. Methods: In a multicentre
retrospective study, 422 patients were included in the study. The
patients were divided into two groups according to whether sURS was to
be performed. Patients’ demographics, stone parameters and operative
outcomes were compared. Surgical success was defined as no or up to 3-mm
residual stone fragments without the need for additional procedures. The
independent predictors for surgical success were determined with a
multivariable logistic regression model. Results: Of the 422 patients,
133 (31.5%) were in the sURS group and 289 (68.5%) were in the
non-sURS group. Operation time in the sURS group was significantly long
(p<0.0001). A ureteral access sheath (UAS) could not be placed
in four (3.0%) patients in the sURS group, nor in 25 (8.7%) patients
in the non-sURS group (p=0.03). Compared with the non-sURS group, the
intraoperative complication rate was low in the sURS group (14 (4.8%)
vs 1 (0.8%), p=0.04). The surgical success rate was higher in the sURS
group (p=0.002). Nevertheless, sURS had no independent effect on
surgical success. We have found two independent predictors for surgical
success rate: stone number (p<0.0001, OR:2.28) and failed UAS
placement (p=0.035, OR:3.49) Conclusion: Optical dilatation with sURS
before RIRS increases surgical success by raising the rate of UAS
placement and reducing the rate of intraoperative complications. We
suggest that this method can be routinely applied in the group of
patients who have not been passively dilated with a JJ stent